Welcome to AVReview
  •  
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Advice
  • Member Reviews
  • Forum
  • Shop
  • Competitions
Home > News : Speaker reviews
Friday 3 September 2010 | Personalise | Help  
 SPEAKER REVIEWS 04 / 05 / 07
 

Group test: Standmount speakers £500-£1,200

By Dave Oliver

< Previous page

Overview
Price: £500
More info: Quad
Size (WxHxD): 205x330x253mm
Weight: 6.9kg
Drivers: 1x 6.5in (170mm) Kevlar cone mid/bass, 1x 1” (25mm) tweeter
Frequency response: 45Hz - 28kHz
Nominal impedance: 8 Ohms
Power handling: 100 Watts
Sensitivity: 88dB/Watt
Finish: Piano black, rosewood, cherry, maple, bird's eye, silver

Quad 12L2

Launched last autumn, the L2 series is designed to update Quad's popular L-series with new aluminium voice coils, new-look tweeter pod, improved chassis designed to cut down on midrange distortion and improved terminals, spikes and plinths.

The second biggest in the range, they're not the best looking of the bunch on test - big, room-dominating glossy boxes (our test pair came in piano black, which didn't help, although there's a range of less brutal-looking wood finishes) - they're not the shy and retiring type. They are however twin-ported at the rear and offer the opportunity of bi-wiring - the only one of these speakers to offer this.

Thankfully, the sound more than makes up for the lack of subtlety in the design. These speakers do a marvellous job of pulling together all the sonic elements to produce a beautifully presented sonic image. Plenty of punch from the mid/bass Kevlar driver, which exerts a strong degree of control on the low end while presenting the midrange beautifully, with insight and no little taste - you feel you can hear everything, but no element seems to dominate unnecessarily.

The tweeter meanwhile offers a marvellously transparent view of the higher frequencies and blends very smoothly with the rest of the sonic picture - it doesn't offer quite the same degree of space as some of the models here, particularly the Dali or the Focal, but the cohesion of the overall image is exemplary - it's a very fine speaker.

Verdict
Plus points
Marvellously integrated sonic image, no shortage of bass
Minus points
Unsubtle, blocky looks, tweeter can feel a bit 'shut in' with very high frequencies

Overview
Price: £1,200
More info: Tannoy
Size (WxHxD): 210x345x130mm
Weight: 4kg
Drivers: 1x 4” (100mm) mixed fibre pulp cone, 1x 3/4” (19mm) titanium dome with neodymium magnet system
Frequency response: 68Hz- 54kHz
Nominal impedance: 8 Ohms
Power handling: 200 Watts
Sensitivity: 88dB/Watt
Finish: Teak

Tannoy Autograph Mini

Tannoy's deceptively small boxes are actually based on the first speaker the company ever produced, 50 years ago. That's not to say that they're antiques though - the look might be retro but the technology certainly isn't.

The rear of the cabinet is angled inwards, which not only serves to decrease the possibility of standing waves inside, but also allows closer placement within corners, if you're pushed for space.

The Autograph Minis deliver a beautifully presented soundstage - precise in its positioning and teasing out a wealth of detail in the midrange, without coming over as nerdily analytical. They deliver a rich, full sound, without the sense that bandwidth is being squashed. With acoustic music such as Gillian Welch's Soul Journey or Björk's vocal-only Medúlla album, the results are exemplary.

When you want to get heavier, say with Basement Jaxx's bass-heavy Good Luck, they still hold things beautifully together - some will miss the distinct lack of bass punch, but this is a small speaker, and as a great man once said, 'Ye cannae change the laws of physics'.

Placing them close to the wall helps boost the low end slightly, but even without the bass reach of some of the models here, when it comes to precision, accuracy and cohesion, they punch well above their (very light) weight.

Verdict
Plus points
Very small and compact, distinctive retro look, beautifully precise sound
Minus points
Distinctive retro look, not much bass punch, not cheap

Final verdict
A very fine bunch of speakers this, and as ever, there are horses for courses. The Focal-JMlab Chorus 807 Vs certainly have their place but it probably wasn't in our listening room. These big and bulky numbers certainly made their presence felt but lacked the ability to pull the sound together in a rewarding way, though a larger room (or the smaller 806 version) might have helped.

The Tannoy Autograph Mini is a beautiful little speaker if your tastes run to the middle of the last century. And even if they don't, they're a classy looking performer that put out a beguilingly cohesive picture, albeit one that's lacking in low-end throb. The Quad 12L2 is a very fine speaker that presents a superbly cohesive sonic picture, albeit without quite the nth detail in the high-end or low-end punch of some of the others here.

But it's the Dali Mentor 1 that takes the honours on the day. It makes a virtue of its emphasis on the higher range with its unusual hybrid tweeter but also proved to be a fine all-rounder, though you'll need to take care to partner it with sympathetic electronics.

< Previous page

AVR Glossary

Bookmark thisPrinter friendly version
Want to send this article to a friend? Please join here
 

Discuss this article, 1 of 22 messages, read more:
Mick Cox 
Posted: 10/05/07 16:24:17 17
Hi there,

I cannot reasonably understand how you can compare the £500 Quads with £1200 Tannoys. The difference here is £700 in price, surely it would have been fairer to have all the speakers of roughly the same value ie. £1000 to £1200 or £500 to £600 as in the case of the Quads. To me it does not seem a fair asessment whatsoever.


Regards


Mick Cox
Read more...
Read member reviews:
Standmount speakers (279 products)
Focal-Jmlab Chorus 807 V
Quad 12L2
Dali Mentor 1
Tannoy Autograph Mini
Related articles:
Audio Pro Mondial loudspeaker
Not painted, not veneered but upholstered!
ATC SCM16A loudspeaker
Desktop speaker with plenty of oomph

Support our sponsors
Join AVReview login to AVReview
Forgotten your password? | Why should I join AVReview?
Shopping
Digital Direct UK
Sound and Vision
Hifi Cables Direct
The Flat TV Company
The Plasma Centre
Support our sponsors
Join Now
Top of Page
About AVReview
- About Us
- Privacy Policy
- Terms and Conditions

Subscribe to AVREVIEW RSS news feed.
Contact Us
- Support
- Advertise with us
- FAQ
- Retailers: free site review
Magicalia Digital Publishing
Active network
- AVReview
- BIKEmagic
- GOLFmagic
- OUTDOORSmagic
- RoadCyclingUK
- Visordown
Parenting network
- Junior
- MadeForMums
- Practical Parenting
- ThinkBaby

- Full Portfolio
Part of the Magicalia Active network
© 1999-2010 Magicalia Ltd.