Home » News > Speaker reviewsThursday 24 July 2008 | Personalise | Help  
Free AVR membership
Join AVReview now

When you become a member you can:
- Enter great competitions
- Write your own reviews
- Chat in the forum
- Receive a weekly FREE newsletter

why join?  
Ecosse
Forum Hot Threads
21592 Total Messages
What music do you like?
by sbrunette
DH labs power cord vs zion pe power cord
by stephen nicholas
Perceptions
by electrohead
No Blu-ray Drive for Xbox 360
by Jason Evans 2
» Loads More Threads
Latest Reviews
1489 Total Reviews
van den Hul DIY Speaker Connectors
by Martin Brophy
Panasonic DMR-E75VEBS DVD & Video Combi
by Elwyn Currier
DNM Reson with Eichmann Bullet plugs
by Matthew Barker
DNM Reson with Eichmann Bullet plugs
by Alexandru Trutiu
Panasonic DMP-BD30
by Martin Baker
» Loads More Reviews
Meet The AVR Team
Psst! Ever wondered who's behind all of AVReview's brilliant content? Well, click here for the lowdown on our writers...
Most Active Members
... in the last 30 days
1.Tamara Bioylin
2.Bill Colborne
3.Carl Kirby
4.John Fisher
5.electrohead
6.David Mellor
7.wotslice
8.Dave Oliver
9.Gerald Racklin
10.Maurice Allen
See all active members
 SPEAKER REVIEWS 07 / 05 / 06
 

Group test: Stereo speakers under £500

Despite all the advances in hi-fi electronics it's still speakers that play the most important part in your stereo system. And upgrading to a pair of midrange priced speakers offers undeniable improvements to your musical performance.

Speaker design may not have changed much over time but engineering expertise and the use of quality components at this level affords better overall performance than lower priced budget models - so it's worth spending a bit extra.

Standmount models are popular for their slight size but we've brought together four high-performance models capable of delivering a sound that's anything but inconspicuous.


Overview
Price: £450
More info: Acoustic Energy
Size (HxWxD): 450x230x300mm
Weight: tbc
Drive units: 25mm soft dome tweeter; 2 x 11cm alloy mid/bass drivers
Sensitivity: 90dB
Impedance: 6 ohms
Power handling: 175W
Frequency response: 42Hz-23kHz
Port: Rear-firing
Finishes: 3

Acoustic Energy Aelite Two

For a pair of standmount speakers the Aelite Twos appear oversized but the increased dimensions do allow enough room to house a triplet of drivers offering a more substantial, dynamic sound.

Exceptional build quality features a real wood construction using curved cabinets that not only appear attractive but also help improve rigidity and reduce debilitating standing waves.

At the front is a pair of medium-sized alloy mid/bass drivers separated by a central 25mm soft dome tweeter while the rear features a flared port and decent, bi-wireable binding posts.

The speakers are best positioned given plenty of free space with the foam port plugs removed. And, as the size suggests, the sound is impressively commanding with scale to spare - even in larger rooms.

Aside from their undisputed authority, dynamics are well paced and precise - escalating from subtle to ear shattering notes with consummate ease. And the expressive midrange integrates excellently with focused high frequencies. In fact, it's only the slightly vague low frequency performance that separates it from all-rounders like the Epos M12.2s.

As long as heavily defined bass isn't your only criteria, Acoustic Energy's superbly constructed Aelite Twos produce a powerful yet cultured performance that will please most listeners.

Verdict
Plus points
Build quality; authoritative; extensive dynamics
Minus points
Comparatively soft low frequencies

Overview
Price: £500
More info: ATC
Size (HxWxD): 300x160x205mm
Weight: 7kg
Drive units: 25mm soft dome tweeter; 150mm treated polyester weave mid/bass driver
Sensitivity: 84dB
Impedance: 8 ohms
Power handling: 50-300W
Frequency response: 60Hz-20kHz
Port: None
Finishes: 2 (Rosewood £563)

ATC SCM7

ATC has a 30-year hi-fi heritage and is one of the few manufacturers to produce both commercial and professional speakers. And the SCM7s summon that engineering experience to deliver a high-calibre, all-consuming sound.

The speakers have been around for a while and the straight-edged construction featuring a metal plate front baffle appears dated alongside newer models.

But they are superbly constructed using proprietary ATC designs for both drive units with a huge magnet assembly that accounts for the surprising weight from such diminutive dimensions. And you can choose a classy rosewood finish for an inflated cost.

The SCM7s are more sensitive to positioning than their test rivals. They're best placed away from walls and experimenting with the toe-in angle will see patience rewarded. In action, the SCM7s assemble a wonderfully open and articulate soundstage that lures you into the music with excellent stereo imaging.

The clean delivery is doused in detail with impressive midrange realism and decisive high frequency performance. However, while low frequencies are well paced and punchy, the speakers struggle to delve the same bass depths of B&W's CM1s and there's some distortion at high levels.

ATC's SCM7s have aged effortlessly with a timeless, faithful sound that will delight anyone not totally addicted to bass.

Verdict
Plus points
Open soundstage; clean, detailed delivery
Minus points
Dated design; lacks heavy bass definition

Overview
Price: £500
More info: B&W
Size (HxWxD): 280x165x276mm
Weight: 6.7kg
Drive units: 25mm aluminum dome tweeter; 130mm woven Kevlar mid/bass driver
Sensitivity: 84dB
Impedance: 8 ohms
Power handling: 30-100W
Frequency response: 45Hz-50kHz
Port: Rear-firing
Finishes: 3

B&W CM1

B&W's new CM1 speakers have supplemented a classic design with contemporary engineering to produce a speaker that looks as impressive as it sounds.

The CM1's timeless design, featuring beautifully constructed real wood cabinets finished with magnetically attached grilles, aesthetically outclasses its test rivals - especially when supported by the optional FS700 stands (£200). Internally, technologies have been taken from the much-praised 800 Series including the crossover, Kevlar cone mid/bass driver, Nautilus tapered-tube tweeter and Flowport engineering. The consequence of all this 21st Century electro-acoustic expertise would appear to be outstanding musical performance.

The compact cabinets are deceptively deep and best positioned on solid stands away from walls - although there is an optional port sleeve that allows you to experiment with placement against walls. For the smallest speakers in the test the CM1s deliver a surprisingly big sound that refuses to falter at high volumes, and taut low frequencies add plenty of punch to the performance.

But the sound is also enviably refined with superb balance and accurate detail especially from the articulate midrange. Musical timing could be better compared to the Epos M12.2s and low-level dynamics are occasionally obscured but the effect on overall performance is minimal.

The CM1s offer state-of-the-art engineering under a traditional guise with a performance that comes close to class leading at this price.


Verdict
Plus points
Attractive design; surprisingly powerful; refined
Minus points
Rhythmical timing

Overview
Price: £450
More info: Epos
Size (HxWxD): 380x200x250mm
Weight: 8kg
Drive units: 25mm soft dome tweeter; 2x 11cm alloy mid/bass drivers
Sensitivity: 87dB
Impedance: 8 ohms
Power handling: 120W
Frequency response: 58Hz-20kHz
Port: Rear-firing
Finishes: 3

Epos M12.2

The Epos M12.2s evolved from the entry-level M12 and moved into the midrange courtesy of some recent refinements including a new aluminum drive chassis and real wood veneer front baffle. The upshot is extraordinary performance that surpasses the price.

The standard two-way design features a 150mm polypropylene mid/bass driver and 25mm metal dome tweeter, both designed in the UK. But it's the simplicity of the crossover that dictates performance - the exceptional roll-off integration between drivers means there's virtually no crossover at all. The cabinets are well constructed and stylish while two sets of binding posts offer bi-wiring options.

Placed on solid stands and slightly 'toed-in' the M12.2s produce an instantly engaging and honest sound with excellent clarity and cohesion. Far reaching dynamics and a rhythmical sense of timing welcome soundtracks from practically any musical genre with open arms. And the easy listening experience is enhanced by a detailed, expressive midrange and tightly controlled low frequencies. At the high end, the metal dome tweeter occasionally upsets the balance but that eventually fades the longer you use them.

It's not difficult to understand why Epos's M range has picked up so many awards and the M12.2s can compete as class leaders against many more expensive speakers.

Verdict
Plus points
Musical timing; composed, honest sound
Minus points
Unbalanced high frequencies

Final verdict
All of these speakers are among the finest you'll find at this price point and each model has its own attributes that may suit some individual preferences more than others. So, in a test based on such subjective tastes we always recommend listening before you part with any cash.

Still, in a closely fought contest we've decided it's Epos's M12.2s that are left as the last speakers standing. Simplicity reigns supreme and it's the M12.2's easily listening appeal and all-round ability based on clarity and cohesive timing that wins the day - not to mention the attractive price.

Both B&W's new CM1s and the older ATC SCM7s come a close second. But it's the B&W's comparative lack of timing and ATC's inability with true bass definition that separates them from first place. Acoustic Energy's Aelite Twos also struggle with low-frequency precision and their oversized construction could pose a problem to some.

AVR Glossary


Bookmark thisPrinter friendly version
Want to send this article to a friend? Please join here
 

Comment on this in our forum:
 You say:
Using this form will also register you with the site.
Forum Topic:
Thread title:
Description: (optional)
Message:
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Email: *
Security Image:This is a security image
Write the characters shown in the image above (Case sensitive)
I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct
E-mail me when a response is made?
Read member reviews:
Standmount speakers (254 products)
Epos M12.2 Bookshelf Speakers (1 review)
Acoustic Energy AELITE 2 Bookshelf Speakers
Related articles:
Onkyo DR-815 micro CD/universal DVD receiver
It’s an AV TARDIS
Epos M series sub and floorstander
Blow away the winter blues with these new audio titans...
Group test: Audio DACs
Hotwire your hi-fi with an audio DAC...
Group test: Floorstanding speakers £400-£1,000
Floorstanders don't necessarily take up more room than standmounts...
New ATC passive loudspeakers
The SCM range gets a power upgrade...
Review: Revolver AudioVue 2S surround system
A quality surround system that fades into the background - in a good way...
New Acoustic Energy products
This year's Bristol Show was packed with new products from pretty much every manufacturer you can think of. At the Acoustic Energy stand the company unveiled a load of new models that cover the hi-fi, AV and the ever-growing iPod market...
Bowers & Wilkins CM1 ‘mini-monitor’ speaker
Bowers & Wilkins has added a new speaker to their range, the CM1.
Group test: Budget speakers
Even at the entry level, speakers have the most crucial effect on the overall sound performance of your stereo system – so, if music matters, this is the place to start...
Review: Epos ELS 303 floorstanding loudspeaker
The ELS 303 is designed with stereo music playback in mind, though it wouldn’t be out of place in a full 5.1 surround system...
Acoustic Energy AELITE On-wall speaker
Acoustic Energy has added to its existing AELITE series of loudspeakers with the release of the On-wall speaker. The On-wall is a high performance speaker designed to be wall mounted vertically or...
Loudspeakers - advanced buying guide
Seasoned audiophiles and numerous industry experts often agree that the loudspeaker is the most influential link in the hi-fi system. Indeed, changing your speakers is the single action guaranteed to have the most profound effect on the overall...
Epos ELS3 standmount/bookshelf speakers reviewed
Epos made its name with a standmount loudspeaker with impressive timing skills called the ES14 back in the eighties, then as now the brand’s approach was minimalist; don’t use crossover components unless you have to...
ATC SCM35 review
Surprisingly this is the first passive floorstander from Gloucester-based ATC. While the speaker world at large has been turning to floorstanders for their aesthetic advantages Stroud’s finest have stuck with standmounts...

Members Logon
Email:
Password:
forgot your
password?
Article search
   

Send to friend | Join Now ^ Top of Page
About AVReview
- About Us
- Privacy Policy
- Terms and Conditions

Subscribe to AVREVIEW RSS news feed.
Contact Us
- Support
- Advertise with us
- FAQ
- Retailers: free site review
Magicalia Digital Publishing
Cycling
- BIKEmagic
- RoadCyclingUK
- SheCycles
- LondonCycleSport
- Visordown
- ProTourNews
Outdoors
- OUTDOORSmagic
- FISHINGmagic
- GOLFmagic
- TheMainSail
Lifestyle
- ThinkBaby
- Gardening.co.uk
- AVReview
- ThinkCamera
Hobbies
- ModelFlying
- MilitaryModelling
- ModelBoats
- GetWoodWorking

- Full Portfolio
© 1999-2008 Magicalia Ltd.